Casey Shea, Director of SEO/GEO/AEO at Rocket Clicks, joins E-Coffee with Experts to talk about growing family law firms through search when rankings alone don’t bring in clients. Rocket Clicks has been around since 2008 and now works only with family law firms, using the playbook it built while growing its sister company, Sterling Law Firms, across Wisconsin and Illinois.

Casey shares the story of a client ranking number one in the Map Pack month after month while qualified leads stayed flat, and how a closer look at reviews and competitors explained the gap. He draws on his background as a behavioral specialist to explain why intent beats keywords in legal search, where people make decisions out of emotion and urgency, and why publishing a blog to plug a ranking hole rarely solves the real problem.

The conversation also covers AI search. Casey explains why AI checks off-site trust signals like citations and NAP consistency before it treats you as a source, why he sees LLMs.txt files as mostly snake oil, how site architecture should follow the user’s journey, and why reviews matter more than ever. His advice for 2027 is simple: go back to SEO foundations, because well-done SEO still shows up in AI.

Takeaways:

  1. Ranking first in the Map Pack doesn't guarantee qualified leads.
  2. Competitors with far more reviews can win the trust you're missing.
  3. Legal searches are driven by emotion, urgency, and life-changing events.
  4. Ask what searchers want to protect, change, and what stops them.
  5. A new blog won't fix a funnel problem you haven't diagnosed.
  6. AI checks off-site citations and NAP consistency before citing you.
  7. Casey sees LLMs.txt as snake oil; correct schema does the job.
  8. Keep your exact business name, LLC included, so bots don't guess.
  9. Internal links should follow the user's journey from hub to answer.
  10. Solid SEO foundations still carry over to AI search visibility.